The death of global warming: Sustainability 2.0 and design’s dirty little secret
by Scot Herbst on November 3, 2008 05:08 PM

Escape with me for a few moments here – let’s play a visualization game. Close your eyes. You’ve inherited the role of Climate-Change Agent Alpha. You’re a relatively affluent consuming American, capable of meeting the fight against carbon emissions head-on. Your typical day looks something like this:

Wake up in the morning; refer to a series of wall-mounted monitors in your home that give you an endless relay of appliance energy consumption. You escape to work in a hybrid vehicle equipped with an unavoidable heads-up display offering a relentless series of digital algorithms to immediately inform your driving power usage. You’re greeted at work by an active-energy savings billboard espousing the minute-by-minute virtues of the power friendly LEED certified building. Throughout your day you refer to a special app on your cell phone that intermittently monitors your homes regenerative solar capacity. And finally, at day’s end, you retire confidently, having seen your ‘smart-home’ monitor flash a graphic depicting your ‘carbon neutrality’ for the day! An endless blitz of data and graphic information injected into your cognition, affording you the tools to continue consuming, eating and breathing in a responsible manner. The assumption could be that given an ambiguous concept like the ‘carbon footprint,’ we need constant reminders of our mission’s grand purpose. Mission accomplished Climate-Change Agent Alpha. You’ve made the world one day better by staving off your footprint… right?

The painful reality is this: your ‘carbon footprint’ isn’t a ‘footprint’ at all. It’s airborne. Intangible. An esoteric concept, blown around with the winds of political opportunism. Politicians literally script environmental treatises from the leather seats of their Lear Jets, in a frenzied effort to simultaneously win voter approval and justify their omnipotent role as ‘great messenger change-agent’ bearing a torch too important to be saddled with the burden of personal accountability. Even the science behind global warming is fuzzy. For every renowned scholar identifying the human causes of the global warming trend, another laureate emerges with an empirical analysis citing that same warming trend since the last ice age 10,000 years ago. Then there’s population growth. GDP. Consumption. It’s not going to slow down. Ideology is no match for economics. Bundle this fundamental reality with campaign rhetoric and add to that a litany of ‘green’ marketing slogans on the sides of boxes and you’ve left with one thing: Green Fatigue.

And through it all, design’s dirty little secret is this: we're still more concerned with sustaining humans on the face of the earth than the earth itself, and most of our efforts go toward mitigating externalities rather than changing fundamentals. As designers and engineers we can effect no greater change than the influence that our creations have on the lives of humans in the supply chain. Go to China; see unventilated buildings filled with men painting computer chassis devoid of a single respirator. Go to India and watch the chrome-plating process in all of its glory, the effluents attacking clean water supplies. Or look domestically; stripping metals from discarded electronics has been deemed too sensitive a process by the EPA, forcing spent printed circuit boards to fill cargo containers on the return trip to the Far East for unregulated human handling.

The design community is fortunate to work with companies and organizations with RoHS (restriction on hazardous substances, as originally defined by the EU) compliance. HP is one of LUNAR’s most devoted allies on the front to reduce the downstream effect of product development, and is now fully RoHS compliant across its portfolio spanning thousands of SKUs. But ultimately, the responsibility falls on each of us as individuals involved in the sourcing process. Effecting an immediate impact on a human-scale should be the primary focus of our sustainability efforts.

For too long politics have hijacked the environmental dialogue in an effort to cram ‘global warming’ down our throats, and as the global economy cools off we’ll have time to formulate a new approach to our collective efforts before the manufacturing machine again heats up to critical mass...get ready for Sustainability 2.0: Human Sustainability.

For a glimpse of the efforts we’re undertaking @ LUNAR, visit http://lunarelements.blogspot.com/ to view the Designer’s Field Guide to Sustainability.

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Top of mind

  • Technology and The Environment Sessions at the International Consumer Electronics Show hone in on some of the most important steps forward the CE industry has taken, from Energy Star advances to best practices in recycling and energy consumption. Las Vegas, Nevada, January 8-11, 2009

  •  Eco-designers are invited to submit their consumer electronics innovations for prizes and recognition at the Greener Gadget Conference, where industry luminaries meet to discuss the future of CE sustainability. Entry deadline is January 15, 2009. Conference will be held in New York, NY, February 27, 2009.

  • Americana International combines a conference program, trade show and international business matchmaking forum among environmental industries that include municipal and industrial wastewater, soil remediation and groundwater, ecoengineering, bioeconomy and life cycle analysis. Montreal, Canada, March 17-19, 2009.

  • Ethical Sourcing Forum North America 2009 spotlights sustainable business practices currently transforming global supply chains. Topics include sustainable purchasing, food, agriculture, and beverage sector, environmental measurement and monitoring and supply chain rating/reporting. New York City, March 26-27, 2009.

  • The Green Business Certification Workshop provides seminars on green marketing, developing partnerships and greening your operations. Participants receive Clean Air Green Business Certification from the Clean Air Institute. Ft. Collins, CO, January 30 – February 1, 2009.

  • The Green Travel Summit convenes a forum for corporate travel, meetings and incentive professionals, and progressive travel service providers to discuss the risks and rewards of building a sustainable travel and meetings strategy. Newport, CA, March 22, 2009.

  • The 8th International Electronics Recycling Congress offers a platform for government, business and academic participants to discuss how manufacturers can close the recycling loop. Salzburg, Austria, January 21-23, 2009.

  • 2009 Good Jobs, Green Jobs National Conference will forge an agenda for creating jobs and new technologies to reduce global warming, increase our energy independence and promote a healthful environment. This year's conference will also include a Green Jobs Expo. Washington DC, February 4, 2009.

  • Best marketing for sustainable energy will be awarded at the World Sustainable Energy Days 2009 conference, 25 – 27 February 2009, Wels/Upper Austria. Deadline for submission is 15 January 2009.

  • World Critical Resources Summit brings together 300 world leaders to facilitate solutions to sustain, expand, and protect the world's critical resources, including shelter, water, food, energy, medicine, and children. January 5th, 2009, New York.

  • A Greener Europe. The European Commission proposed a legislative package last month aimed at improving the environmental performance and energy efficiency of products and stimulating their market uptake.

  • Greener Chrysler Plant Expansion. From recycled paint sludge to replanted prairie grass, Chrysler incorporates environmentally friendly features in a Detroit plant.

  • High Tech, Low Marks. Global executives are concerned about climate change, but they aren't taking action in the supply chain that could address the issue and reduce costs, according to a McKinsey & Co report.

  • The Designer’s Field Guide to Sustainability, by our blog contributor Travis Lee, offers practical suggestions for incorporating sustainable thinking in everyday design.

  • Simplicity Saves the Day: BNN speaks with Paul Polak, founder, International Development Enterprises (IDE), a new for-profit company D-Rev, and author of Out of Poverty.

  • Carbon dioxide produced by the high-tech industry is expected to triple by 2020. Here’s how companies like Google, Cisco, HP, Sun, Intel and Microsoft are working to reduce global emissions.

  • A growing movement among designers, engineers, students and professors and architects is exploring designing and developing low-cost solutions for the 'other 90%'.

  • A new milk jug is green in almost every way – except consumers don’t like it. Here's how the manufacturer is educating consumers to change their perception.

Creative Commons License